Schtick ruled Saturday's concert at the Taste of Chicago, headlined
by Harry Connick Jr.
First, WLUP radio personalities Kevin Matthews and Danny Bonaduce talked
up and warmed up the crowd. Next came actor/comedian Larry Miller with
his self-deprecating humor. Then Connick arrived in his latest
incarnation: da funkmeister. Or what he called funk, anyway.
If George Clinton were in the grave, he'd be spinning like a dervish.
"Elevator Funk" is the best description of Connick's drollery which,
like his "Frank Sinatra Lite phase," is merely competent and
unthreatening.
Performing for tens of thousands of fans at the Petrillo Music Shell,
Connick kicked off his world tour with a New Orleans-flavored excursion
to his musical roots. Different styles abounded as he shifted from
the galloping beat of "How Do Ya'll Know," to a boogie-woogie piano
number, to a gospel medley of "Jesus on the Mainline" and "This Little
Light of Mine."
But under Connick's hand, all these styles became little bits of
saccharine, devoid of real feeling. His slick show had about as much
sincerity as Joe Isuzu's patter, closer to Hollywood than New Orleans.
There was even a Laurence Fishburne cameo, as the actor came onstage
to lend a vocal assist during the encore.
But oh, that band. Guitarist Jonathan DuBose Jr., bassist Tony Hall,
drummer Raymond Weber, trombonist Lucien Barbarin, percussionist Dave
Miller and local baritone saxman Dave Schumacher were far better
than their material. Allowed to stretch out, free of Connick's
nanities, their free-flowing rhythms made your feet want to move.
But back to that Connick fellow, who was a problem: The musical pastiche
that is his latest style was ultimately unconvincing, saddled by a
self-conscious "ain't I cute"-ness. His performance of the first single
from new album Star Turtle, "Hear Me in the Harmony," lurched
along like a lame Neville Brothers parody.
Connick also flitted from instrument to instrument, noodling around on
electric guitar and bass, in addition to his herky-jerky piano stylings.
This concert left you thinking: As a musician, Harry Connick Jr. is a
fine showman.