For starters, it's something of a shock -- not quite a Roth-rejoins-VH
shock, but startling all the same -- that Harry Connick Jr. has
returned to assault modern pop with the Dr. Hook-meets-Dr. John
finesse that he unleashed two years ago with She. While he eventually
managed to squeak out a minor hit with "(I Could Only) Whisper Your
Name," its airplay seemed more like a concession to a matinee idol who
managed to attach his voice to a jaunty tune.
Connick's celebrity status still stands as a direct result of his days
as an ersatz Sinatra -- not as a pouty supporting actor, supermodel
husband or gun-toting neo-conservative pin-up. To a certain degree,
that's a crying shame -- at least since I assume I'm the only new fan
that he'd managed to earn after shifting musical gears.
Star Turtle is unabashedly branded as a concept album -- something
about a tortoise from outer space who crawls around Bourbon Street --
and, unlike the last time, Harry is serving as his own lyricist. Yet
he's continuing to operate on the premise that bourgeois rock is best
served in a Battlestar Galactica-inspired setting, while the voice of
the turtle itself is given a synthesized Lorne Greene-style timbre.
Being split into three distinct sections helps Star Turtle's vamps to
flow in a more digestible fashion. The first cluster is the least
complicated, where Connick gets strangely comfortable spouting
exhortations like "whacka-whacka-whacka-whacka-wham." Basically, he's
fashioning himself as a less anxiety-prone version of Billy Joel,
especially on "Hear Me In the Harmony." The proceedings get a lot more
blistering around the middle, as Harry breaks out the mini-Moog and
the guitars get much more intense -- that his vocals here are most
reminiscent of Barry Manilow is hardly a hindrance.
Conversely, the last few tracks reveal a Connick who's determined to
be mundane -- with an undercurrent of calculation that's destined to
be viewed with the same head-shaking inscrutability as, say, Michael
Jordan's baseball career. In the meantime, simply savor the fact that
Harry is an inveterate oddball: he's gone from being a 20-year-old who
preens like it's forever 1940 to a 30-year-old who's concluded that
the American popular song reached a state of stylistic perfection in
1980.